About “rare” eclipse intervals and broken periods

Updated: 19  July 2008

This web document explores some of the characteristics of rarely occurring eclipse intervals of 34, 101 and 257 lunations. The 34 lunation interval is a short eclipse series of 3 eclipses, each separated by 17 lunations. The 101 and 257 lunations intervals are closely linked to the 34 lunations interval. Another finding is that the 101 lunation periods are closely linked to the rare eclipse duo’s where one of the eclipses is total.

Introduction

According to G. van den Bergh the interval P in lunations between two solar eclipses can be described by P = a I + b S, where I is the Inex period of 358 lunations, and S the Saros period of 223 lunations and a and b are integer numbers (positive, negative or zero). Off course, simple mathematics show that these periods can also be described by P =  n A + m B, where all numbers are integer, and A and B can be anything, provided A is not a multiple of  B or vice versa. However, using I and S gives some special insights used further in this article, see e.g. figure1.

Next to Saros (223) and Inex (358), various authors (Van Gent, Verbelen) have mentioned a number of well known other eclipse cycles. Some of these are shown in table 1.

Name

Lunations

Formula

Max # of eclipses in cycle

Semester

6

5I – 8S

10

Hexon

35

– 8I + 13S

6

Hepton

41

– 3I + 5S

16

Octon

47

2I – 3S

25

Tzolkinex

88

 – I + 2S

36

Tritos

135

I – S

70

Metonic Cycle

235

10I – 15S

5

Semanex

311

– I + 3S

27

Table 1: Some eclipse cycles
Note: the maximum number of eclipses in cycle is based on the eclipses from the 5 millennium catalog of Espenak & Meeus.

The interval between two eclipses

The interval between two successive solar eclipses is either 1, 5 or 6 lunations. Looking at eclipses in general many intervals are possible. Examining the 5 millenium eclipse catalog (11,898 solar eclipses) for eclipse pairs with interval P=aI+bS 1000, versus the sum of the absolute value of a and b, one finds the points displayed in figure 1. 


Figure 1: Frequency of eclipse pairs with interval P=aI+bS  vs abs(a)+abs(b).   P ≤1000

 The most frequent interval is – not unexpected – the Saros. Intervals (P ≤ 1000) that are rare are listed in table 2. 

Interval P (lunations)

a

b

abs(a)+abs(b)

# of pairs

34

-46

74

122

34

101

47

-75

122

10

257

-46

75

121

4

324

47

-74

121

43

682

48

-74

122

9

838

-45

76

121

19

905

48

-73

121

37

Table 2: Some intervals  with low frequency for P ≤ 1000

Several combinations of these rare intervals lead to the well know eclipse cycles such as the Tritos, Saros and Inex.

 34 + 101 = 135 = I – S (Tritos)
257 – 34 = 324 – 101 =  S (Saros)
324 + 34 = 101 + 257 = 358 = I (Inex)

It should therefore be no surprise that these rare intervals are interrelated. Below some more trivia on the 34, 101 and 257 lunation intervals.

34 Lunations – a Double Trion

In a 3 lunar year period (36 lunations) the period between any  two solar eclipses 1, 5, 6, 7, 11, 12, 17, 18, 23, 24, 29, 30, 34, 35 or 36 lunations.

An interesting interval is 34 lunations. This is a combination of 2 successive 17 lunation periods. As the 17 lunations period is three eclipse seasons, Trion would seem to be an appropriate name for it. This would be in line with the names Hexon, Hepton and Octon for 6, 7 and 8 eclipse seasons. While in the 5 Millennium Catalogue there are 5507 Trion pairs, there are only 34 Trion cycle of 2 subsequent Trion pairs. 

These rare Trion cycles start with a small partial eclipse near one of the poles, followed by a central eclipse, annular or total, near the tropics, and they end with a small partial near the opposite pole. Both the first and last eclipse are always part of a duo of solar eclipses.

The 101 lunations interval is always linked to a 34 lunations interval to form a Tritos. The 101 period always starts and ends with a duo eclipse. It is remarkable that a member of one of these duos is either total or almost total (0.999). The first eclipse of a 101 lunation interval is the last of a Saros series, and the second is the first of a new Saros series. All 257 lunation intervals are linked to a 101 lunation period to form a Inex period.

 Very rarely a Trion cycle is followed one Saros period later by another Trion cycle. This happens only 4 times in times in the 5 millennia considered, and leads to the rare 257 lunation period between two solar eclipses. With the 257 lunation interval the first is always the beginning of new Saros and the second is the end of a Saros series.

The tables listing all 34, 101 and 257 lunations period can be found below.

References and suggested reading:

Bergh, prof. mr dr G. van den – Regelmaat en Wisseling bij Zonsverduisteringen, 1951, Tjeenk Willink, Haarlem
Espenak, Fred and Meeus, Jean – Five Millennium Canon of Solar Eclipses: -1999 to +3000,  NASA Technical Publication TP-2006-214141
Meeus, Jean – Mathematical Astronomy Morsels, 1997, Willmann-Bell
Meeus, Jean – More Mathematical Astronomy Morsels, 2000, Willmann-Bell
Meeus, Jean – Mathematical Astronomy Morsels III, 2004, Willmann-Bell
Meeus, Jean – Mathematical Astronomy Morsels IV, 2007, Willmann-Bell
Van Gent, Robert H. – A Catalogue of Eclipse Cycles, update 2003, (http://www.phys.uu.nl/~vgent/eclipse/eclipsecycles.htm)
Verbelen, Felix – Saros, Inex and Eclipse cycles, 2001, (http://users.online.be/felixverbelen/cycles.htm)
Quaglia, Luca and Tilley, John – Saros Inex Panorama, MS-Excel sheet,
(http://sunearth.gsfc.nasa.gov/eclipse/SEsaros/SEpanorama.html)

Tables of 34, 101 and 257 lunation intervals

34 lunations

Ref

Date

 

 

Saros

Type

Gamma

Magni-tude

Remarks

34AA

-1982

Aug

2

33

Pb

1.4996

0.0678

 

 

-1981

Dec

17

10

A

-0.2249

0.9420

 

 

-1979

May

2

-13

Pe

-1.5543

0.0110

 

34AB

-1870

Jul

25

35

Pb

1.56

0.0081

 

 

-1869

Dec

9

12

A

-0.1623

0.9521

 

 

-1867

Apr

24

-11

Pe

-1.4802

0.0973

First of 101A

34AC

-1859

Jun

23

36

Pb

-1.5239

0.0181

Last of 101A
First of 257A
Duo with T+ -1859 May 25

 

-1858

Nov

7

13

A

0.0044

0.9400

 

 

-1856

Mar

24

-10

P

1.4854

0.1309

one but last of Saros -10

34AD

-1841

Jul

4

36

P

-1.4564

0.1461

second of Saros 36

 

-1840

Nov

18

13

A

0.0048

0.9422

 

 

-1838

Apr

4

-10

Pe

1.5615

0.00002

Smallest eclipse in 5MilCat

Last of 257A

34AE

-1794

Jun

25

37

Pb

1.5328

0.0144

 

 

-1793

Nov

9

14

Tm

0.0296

1.0461

 

 

-1791

Mar

25

-9

Pe

-1.5327

0.0211

 

34AF

-1729

Jun

26

38

Pb

-1.5245

0.0649

 

 

-1728

Nov

10

15

A

-0.06

0.9478

 

 

-1726

Mar

27

-8

Pe

1.4941

0.0722

First of P101B

34AG

-1718

May

26

39

Pb

1.5157

0.0319

Last of P101B
Duo with T+ -1718 Apr 27

 

-1717

Oct

10

16

A

0.2176

0.9456

 

 

-1715

Feb

24

-7

Pe

-1.5449

0.0340

 

34AH

-1284

Jul

25

54

Pb

-1.4893

0.0993

 

 

-1283

Dec

9

31

A

0.1275

0.9205

 

 

-1281

Apr

26

8

Pe

1.5267

0.0471

 

34AI

-1255

Jul

6

55

Pb

1.5161

0.0296

 

 

-1254

Nov

19

32

T

-0.045

1.0285

 

 

-1252

Apr

4

9

Pe

-1.5425

0.0226

 

34AJ

-1172

Jul

17

56

Pb

-1.5509

0.0224

 

 

-1171

Dec

2

33

A

0.0291

0.9864

 

 

-1169

Apr

18

10

Pe

1.4971

0.0590

First of 101C
Duo with T -1169 May 17

34AK

-1161

Jun

17

57

Pb

1.5268

0.0278

Last of 101C
First of 257B

 

-1160

Oct

31

34

A

0.1089

0.9207

 

 

-1158

Mar

18

11

P

-1.4826

0.1282

one but last of Saros 11

34AL

-1143

Jun

27

57

P

1.4501

0.1683

second of Saros 57

 

-1142

Nov

11

34

Am

0.114

0.9209

 

 

-1140

Mar

28

11

Pe

-1.5505

0.0093

Last of 257B

34AM

-1031

Jun

19

59

Pb

1.5201

0.0725

 

 

-1030

Nov

4

36

A

0.194

0.9836

 

 

-1028

Mar

19

13

Pe

-1.5268

0.0054

First of 101D
Duo with T -1028 Apr 18

34AN

-727

Aug

16

72

Pb

-1.5437

0.0212

 

 

-726

Dec

31

49

A

0.2491

0.9215

 

 

-724

May

17

26

Pe

1.5084

0.0628

 

34AO

-604

Jul

7

75

Pb

1.5494

0.0066

First of 257C

 

-603

Nov

22

52

Am

-0.0176

0.9188

 

 

-601

Apr

8

29

P

-1.4489

0.1737

one but last of Saros 29

34AP

-586

Jul

18

75

P

1.4763

0.1354

second of Saros 75

 

-585

Dec

3

52

A

-0.0131

0.9182

 

 

-583

Apr

19

29

Pe

-1.5219

0.0408

First of 101E

Last of 257C

34AQ

-575

Jun

18

76

Pb

-1.5192

0.0156

Last of 101E
Duo with T -575 May 19

 

-574

Nov

1

53

A

-0.1006

0.9947

 

 

-572

Mar

18

30

Pe

1.5567

0.0129

 

34AR

-463

Jun

9

78

Pb

-1.542

0.0174

 

 

-462

Oct

25

55

A

-0.2114

0.9206

 

 

-460

Mar

10

32

Pe

1.5085

0.0679

 

34AS

-159

Aug

6

91

Pb

1.526

0.0126

Last of 101F
Duo with T* -159 Aug 6

 

-158

Dec

21

68

A

-0.1862

0.9514

 

 

-156

May

7

45

Pe

-1.5131

0.0844

 

34AT

-29

Aug

9

93

Pb

1.517

0.0782

 

 

-28

Dec

24

70

A

-0.1161

0.9400

 

 

-26

May

10

47

Pe

-1.5186

0.0287

First of 101G
Duo with T+ -26 Jun 8

34AU

-18

Jul

9

94

Pb

-1.493

0.0727

Last of 101G

 

-17

Nov

23

71

A

-0.0384

0.9533

 

 

-15

Apr

9

48

Pe

1.5403

0.0397

 

34AV

94

Jul

1

96

Pb

-1.5566

0.0070

 

 

95

Nov

16

73

A

-0.1075

0.9396

 

 

97

Apr

1

50

Pe

1.48

0.1036

 

34AW

539

Jul

31

112

Pb

-1.4924

0.0889

 

 

540

Dec

14

89

A

0.0482

0.9243

 

 

542

May

1

66

Pe

1.5211

0.0615

 

34AX

651

Jul

23

114

Pb

-1.5588

0.0086

 

 

652

Dec

6

91

A

-0.0391

0.9771

 

 

654

Apr

22

68

Pe

1.4901

0.0743

First of 101H
Duo with P 654 May 22 0.9990

34AY

662

Jun

21

115

Pb

1.5377

0.0030

 

 

663

Nov

5

92

A

0.1826

0.9265

 

 

665

Mar

22

69

Pe

-1.5106

0.0840

 

34AZ

1096

Aug

20

130

Pb

-1.511

0.0743

 

 

1098

Jan

5

107

A

0.1464

0.9189

 

 

1099

May

22

84

Pe

1.5185

0.0483

 

34BA

1219

Jul

13

133

Pb

1.5337

0.0308

 

 

1220

Nov

26

110

A

0.0907

0.9185

 

 

1222

Apr

13

87

Pe

-1.4863

0.1092

 

34BB

1664

Aug

21

149

Pb

1.487

0.0844

 

 

1666

Jan

5

126

A

-0.0624

0.9562

 

 

1667

May

22

103

Pe

-1.5574

0.0102

 

34BC

1776

Aug

14

151

Pb

1.5357

0.0435

 

 

1777

Dec

29

128

A

0.011

0.9380

 

 

1779

May

16

105

Pe

-1.4928

0.0796

 

34BD

2203

Sep

6

167

Pb

1.5374

0.0067

Last of 101I

 

2205

Jan

21

144

A

-0.1281

0.9241

 

 

2206

Jun

7

121

Pe

-1.4894

0.1166

 

34BE

2344

Aug

9

170

Pb

-1.4974

0.0788

 

 

2345

Dec

24

147

Am

-0.1081

0.9252

 

 

2347

May

11

124

Pe

1.5351

0.0391

 

34BF

2760

Oct

1

185

Pb

1.5442

0.0176

 

 

2762

Feb

16

162

A

-0.1959

0.9211

 

 

2763

Jul

3

139

Pe

-1.5132

0.0562

 

34BG

2883

Aug

23

188

Pb

-1.5524

0.0010

First of 257D

 

2885

Jan

7

165

A

-0.0289

0.9197

 

 

2886

May

25

142

P

1.4742

0.1283

one but last of Saros 142

34BH

2901

Sep

4

188

P

-1.4766

0.1347

second of Saros 188

 

2903

Jan

19

165

A

-0.0391

0.9189

 

 

2904

Jun

5

142

Pe

1.5428

0.0040

First of 101J
Last of 257D

  101 lunations

Ref

Date

 

 

Saros

Type

Magnitude

Remarks

101A

-1867

Apr

24

-11

Pe

0.0973

 

 

-1859

Jun

23

36

Pb

0.0181

–1859 May 25 non-central total

101B

-1726

Mar

27

-8

Pe

0.0722

 

 

-1718

May

26

39

Pb

0.0319

-1718 Apr. 27 non-central total

101C

-1169

Apr

18

10

Pe

0.0590

-1169 May 17 total

 

-1161

Jun

17

57

Pb

0.0278

 

101D

-1028

Mar

19

13

Pe

0.0054

-1028 Apr 18 total

 

-1020

May

18

60

Pb

0.0291

 

101E

-583

Apr

19

29

Pe

0.0408

-575 May 19 total

 

-575

Jun

18

76

Pb

0.0156

 

101F

-167

Jun

7

44

Pe

0.0459

 

 

-159

Aug

8

91

Pb

0.0126

-159 Jul 8 non-central total

101G

-26

May

10

47

Pe

0.0287

-26 Jun 8 non-central total

 

-18

Jul

9

94

Pb

0.0727

 

101H

654

Apr

22

68

Pe

0.0743

654 May 22 almost total 0.999

 

662

Jul

21

115

Pb

0.0030

 

101I

2195

Jul

7

120

Pe

0.0353

2195 Aug 5 total

 

2203

Sep

6

167

Pb

0.0067

 

101J

2904

Jun

5

142

Pe

0.0040

 

 

2912

Aug

4

189

Pb

0.0308

2912 Jul 6 total

  257 lunations

Ref

Date

 

 

Saros

Type

Magnitude

Remarks

257A

-1859

Jun

23

36

Pb

0.0181

End of 101A

 

-1838

Apr

4

-10

Pe

0.00002

 

257B

-1161

Jun

17

57

Pb

0.0278

End of 101C

 

-1140

Mar

28

11

Pe

0.0093

 

257C

-604

Jul

7

75

Pb

0.0066

 

 

-583

Apr

19

29

Pe

0.0408

Start of 101E

257D

2883

Aug

23

188

Pb

0.0010

 

 

2904

Jun

5

142

Pe

0.0040

Start of 101J


All 4 intervals of 257 lunations are combined with a 101 lunations interval to make a full Inex of 358 lunations:  101A & 257A, 101C & 257B, 257C & 101E and finally 257D & 101J

back